Youth Coaches Start Here, Part 3: Does Your Coaching Match Your Philosophy?
New to the series? Start with Part 1: Why Do You Coach? and Part 2: What Kind of Environment Are You Creating?
In Part 1 of this series, we asked:
Why do you coach?
In Part 2, we asked:
What is the environment you are creating and what’s it like to be coached by you?
Now comes the hard part.
Does Your Mission Match How You Coach?
- Development matters.
- Effort matters.
- Every player matters.
- Mistakes are part of learning.
- Character matters more than winning.
- We want kids to enjoy basketball.
Those ideas are easy to say.
They're harder to live when the game is tied with two minutes left.
- When your best player breaks a team rule.
- When a parent questions playing time.
- When an official makes a call you hate.
- Or when winning today conflicts with developing a player for tomorrow.
That's when your coaching philosophy becomes real.
Let Your Philosophy Guide Your Decisions
A coaching philosophy should help you make decisions—especially difficult ones.
You can't predict everything that will happen during a season, but you can decide what principles will guide you.
- If development matters, it should affect practice.
- If every player matters, it should affect how you distribute your attention.
- If respect matters, it should affect how you treat officials.
- If accountability matters, it should apply to all players equally.
Otherwise, your philosophy becomes little more than something you say.
Playing Time Is One of the First Big Tests
Few topics create more emotion in youth sports than playing time.
And there isn't one formula that works for every team.
Age matters. Competition level matters. Commitment matters. League rules matter.
Most importantly, the expectations you communicated before the season matter.
Before making playing-time decisions, ask:
- What is the purpose of this team?
- What did we tell families before the season?
- How important is development at this age?
- Am I developing the entire roster?
Those questions are more useful than simply asking:
Who gives us the best chance to win right now?
Caring about every player doesn't mean pretending every player is the same.
Players have different skill levels, experience, commitment, and roles. They may not receive identical opportunities in every situation.
But there's a big difference between saying:
“Every player has the same role.”
and:
“Every player matters.”
The second should always be true.
Your tenth player should feel coached. They should receive instruction, opportunities to improve, and a clear understanding of how they can earn more responsibility.
Playing time teaches something too.
If only the most physically developed players ever play, what are we teaching?
If a player can ignore team values because they score, what are we teaching?
With young athletes, playing time should be viewed through a development lens, not only a scoreboard lens.
Your Practice Reveals Your Priorities
Suppose you say:
“We're focused on development.”
Now look at your practice.
- Are the best players getting most of the repetitions?
- Are kids standing in long lines, bored, not improving, just wasting time?
- Are you stopping practice constantly for long lectures (where most kids zone out)?
- Are you spending most of your time rehearsing plays while fundamental skills get only a few minutes?
- Are players handling the ball, making decisions, and learning to read the game?
Your practice often reveals your priorities more accurately than your mission statement.
If development matters, protect development time and make it a priority each and every practice.
Don't Trade Development for Control
One of the biggest temptations in youth coaching is trying to control everything.
- Tell every player where to stand.
- Tell the point guard exactly when to pass.
- Call every action from the sideline.
- Remove players immediately after mistakes.
That may produce cleaner basketball today.
But ask yourself:
What are my players learning to do without me?
Eventually, players have to read the game, solve problems, make decisions, and recover from mistakes.
Sometimes that process looks messy.
That's part of development.
What Happens After a Mistake in a Game?
Games make everything more emotional.
A player turns the ball over.
- Do you immediately remove them?
- Throw your hands in the air?
- Yell across the court?
From personal experience I can tell you that when a player travels, they know they aren’t supposed to travel…so yelling “Stop traveling!” at them, may make you feel better, but it wasn’t coaching the player.
Can you give them a quick correction? Maybe you can, if so great. If not, move on and don’t dwell on the mistake.
There are certainly times when a substitution is appropriate.
But make sure it isn't simply an emotional reaction.
If players learn:
“One mistake and I'm coming out,”
they may begin playing not to fail.
That's very different from playing to succeed.
Game Day Is Where Players See the Real You
We tell players:
- “Stay composed.”
- “Next play.”
- “Control what you can control.”
- “Don't blame the officials.”
Then the game starts.
A whistle goes against us.
Now what do we do?
- If you expect composure, model composure.
- If you expect respect, demonstrate respect.
- If you expect players to move on after mistakes, show them how.
That doesn't mean coaching without passion.
But there's a difference between energy and losing control.
You can disagree with an official. You can ask questions and advocate for your team.
But you can't demand emotional control from a 12-year-old while demonstrating none yourself.
Your players are always watching.
Sometimes as a coach, I think yelling at an official is a defense mechanism. It’s easier to blame a call than to look at what we could have done better. But when we do that, we teach our players to make the same excuse.
Winning and Losing Both Test Your Philosophy
Losing is uncomfortable.
- Sometimes your team plays poorly.
- Sometimes the other team is simply better.
- Sometimes you play well and still lose.
What matters is what your players learn afterward.
Instead of a blame session, maybe the message is:
- “We didn't rebound well enough tonight.”
- “We turned it over too much.”
- “Let's learn from it and get back to work.”
Accountability without drama.
But winning can test your philosophy too.
Suppose you're ahead by 30.
Do you keep pressing and feeding your best scorer?
Or do you create opportunities for other players and show respect for the opponent?
Winning doesn't give us permission to abandon our values.
Remember the Two Scoreboards
I introduced the idea of two scoreboards in Part 1.
Youth coaches have to pay attention to two scoreboards.
Scoreboard 1: The Game
Wins. Losses. Score.
Scoreboard 2: Development
- Are our players improving?
- Making better decisions?
- Becoming better teammates?
- Learning to handle adversity?
- Do they want to keep playing?
Both matter.
A winning team may simply be bigger, older, or more talented.
A losing team may still be making tremendous progress.
Wins matter. They just don't tell the whole story.
Your Best Player May Create Your Hardest Decision
Imagine your best player.
They score most of the points and give you the best chance to win.
But they also don't listen.
- They treat teammates poorly.
- They don't sprint back.
- They complain when substituted.
- They ignore team rules.
What do you do?
This is where phrases like:
- “Character matters.”
- “Team first.”
- “Everyone is accountable.”
get tested.
If your best player gets different rules because you're afraid of losing, everyone notices.
Your standard is no longer your standard.
Talent has become the standard.
- You can care about a player and still hold them accountable.
- You can correct behavior without humiliating them.
- You can have standards without creating fear.
The key is consistency.
If your standards change because tonight's opponent is really good, your players will notice.
Talk to Parents Before Problems Happen
Many difficult parent situations become easier when expectations are communicated early.
Before the season, explain:
- What the team is trying to accomplish
- How you define success
- How playing time will generally work
- What behaviors you expect
- How parents should raise concerns
- What role you'd like them to play
Don't assume every family sees youth basketball the same way you do.
Clarity up front can prevent surprises later.
Parents can also become valuable partners.
Encourage them to praise effort, avoid coaching from the stands, support players after mistakes, and model appropriate behavior toward officials and opponents.
And remind them to be careful with the car ride home.
Kids often already know when they played poorly.
They may not need a 20-minute breakdown before leaving the parking lot.
Sometimes:
“I loved watching you play.”
is enough.
If they want to talk basketball, great.
If not, there will be time later.
Youth sports shouldn't make kids dread the ride home.
Make Sure Players Know You Care Beyond Performance
Players need to know your approval doesn't depend entirely on how they perform.
You can be disappointed in a decision without being disappointed in them.
You can correct them and still believe in them.
You can hold them accountable and still be on their side.
That distinction matters.
Evaluate Yourself Too
Coaches spend a lot of time evaluating players.
Sometimes reflecting and evaluating ourselves is the most important thing we can do.
After a practice or game, ask:
- Did I stay composed?
- Did I teach?
- Did I communicate clearly?
- Did I overreact to mistakes?
- Did I model our values?
And perhaps most importantly:
Who were my decisions really for?
- Were they for the player's development?
- The team?
- The long-term health of the program?
- Or were they sometimes about my own ego?
Coaches are human.
We like winning.
We like feeling successful.
We like feeling in control.
But youth coaching isn't supposed to be about proving how good the adult is.
We're there to serve the experience and development of the players.
That question can reset your priorities quickly.
What Will Success Look Like at the End of the Season?
When the season ends, look beyond the record.
- Are your players better?
- Did they improve their skills?
- Did they learn how to compete?
- Did they become better teammates?
- Did they gain confidence?
- Do they want to play again?
If you can answer yes to most of those questions, you've probably accomplished something truly meaningful.
And I keep reminding you, don’t expect to be perfect. Just expect the same thing you expect from your team…keep working hard and trying to improve. Coaching is a process!
The Final Coaching Test
Years from now, your players probably won't remember your record.
They won't remember the tournament bracket.
They probably won't remember your press break or the sideline out-of-bounds play.
But they may remember whether you believed in them.
- Whether you embarrassed them.
- Whether they looked forward to practice.
- Whether you helped them improve.
- Whether you treated them fairly.
- Whether you helped make basketball something they wanted to keep playing.
That's a major responsibility.
And an incredible opportunity.
Create A Strong Foundation For Yourself
There is an enormous amount of basketball to learn as a coach.
Shooting. Defense. Practice organization. Offensive concepts. Decision-making.
All of it matters.
But underneath it all are the three questions we've worked through in this series:
Why do I coach?
What kind of environment do I want to create?
Do my daily decisions reflect those answers?
Get those right and everything else has a stronger foundation.
Because youth coaching isn't only about what offense you run or how many games you win.
It's about what happens to the young people entrusted to you while you're coaching them.
- Help them improve.
- Teach them how to compete.
- Hold them accountable.
- Give them confidence.
- Make basketball something they want to continue.
And years from now, give them a reason to look back and say:
“I was lucky to have that coach.”
Get Your Free Youth Coaching PDFs
4 ready-to-run practice plans and 20+ drills for ages 8 to 13.
Enter your email and we’ll send them straight to your inbox.


Facebook (145k Followers)
YouTube (152k Subscribers)
Twitter (33k Followers)
Q&A Forum
Podcasts